Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts

January 21, 2014

People over _______.

  I have a new core doctrine for myself.  I grew up with an extremely rigid set of beliefs, and having something solid, something black-and-white that I can claim as a personal core belief has been very good for me as a person.

This doctrine is: People over ALL.
People over money, people over religion, people over social status, people over problems, people over disagreements, people over feuds, people over politics, people over pain, people over misunderstandings, and people over _____ (insert word).

Basically, this ties into my traumatic experience with being cut off from my family for my religious beliefs.  Unless I agreed 100% and walked lock-step with my father in all of his doctrine and religious pursuits, I was not welcome in my family, and I am considered a "prodigal daughter."
HOWEVER, my caveat to this is that people (especially and specifically those who are abusers) do not get to be raised over things like safety, common sense, personal boundaries, and personal mental health.  I will not allow my father to come visit me because even though he is a person, he has not earned the right to my trust and my heart.  He lost those with his actions and will not get them ever again.
  I will, though, support his right to life, liberty, his personal property (not my siblings persons, they are not his property), and his ability to pursue personal happiness in being religious.  I will not support his attempts to prosyletize if other people dont want him around because I support other people's right to not want to be bothered over his desire to convert.

I participated in an even with my community college yesterday MLK day and we went around the room with questions written on paper about a gamut of current issues.  My question was: Is your freedom worth someone else's pain?  Your money?  You place (in society/church/whatever)?
  Is your freedom to own guns without checks or mandatory locks or any "government snooping" worth the death of kids by accidental shooting from their siblings, the Newton shooting, or other shootings that will happen after this is posted?
  Is your freedom to run a business your own personal way more important that labor laws or pollution ordinances or the rights of your workers to humane treatment, "nominal" working hours, and a living wage?
  Is your freedom to pay yourself millions of dollars as a CEO and bonuses (and then hide it in offshore accounts) more important than the well being of people who are STARVING because government assistance doesnt feed them adequately?

I think people, and the welfare of these people, should come before the things that can be put aside.
Leading up to this is my firm belief that America should be a bigger welfare state.  My Comparative Government professor talked a little bit about Germany having a pretty capitalist economy but with a solid welfare state that provides not only working comp, but years of maternity and paternity leave, as well as health care for everyone, and education for everyone up to college!

This level of advances people-care could happen in America if people were less focused on greed and personal gain and more focused on bettering the lives of EVERYONE they can.
People over all.

May 21, 2013

TeenPact – My experience (and a lot of parenthesis)


   My mom saw a poster for it on the homeschool group's website. It was being promoted a lot since it was the first year that they gained access to our State. I think I was the ONLY student there who wanted to attend. Amid all the testimonies of hating the fancy (and modest) clothes, hating civics, and it being a struggle to not listen to music or watch television all week, I wondered what was wrong with all these other homeschoolers.

   Yes, I had a lot of pride, but I was raised thinking that homeschooling was better than public school and it was unfortunate that public schoolers could not get a 4 day crash-course of in-depth politics training on a state level. I reveled in the homework and the required modest clothing and I had no problem with the rule about media because my media consumption was already incredibly minuscule. The rules about guy-girl interactions was not a problem because of how strict my father was, and all of the guys there were younger than me and not that appealing.
   I also had a family background in politics (2008 was an election year and my grandparents and older sister were so caught up in the whirlwind that my leaving for so many days was a big deal around the house) which made me the student who knew it all.
And that was a problem. My whole TeenPact experience I was either patronized by staffers and administrators, or I was the problem that they had to deal with and work around.
   One of the staffers inserted a rabbit trail push for John McCain votes/support (we were all too young to vote anyway) and I piped up (in the middle of class) about his immigration bill and his history of non-conservatism. That got me an extremely dirty look from all staffers and I was ignored every time I raised my hand after that...except when no one else knew the answer. (I was down for a couple in-kind contributions to a campaign, so I knew what they were. None of the other students did.)

   I definitely stood out in the class as the only student to ask the Aide to the First Lady (She was also a high-level judge) what (the Judge/First Lady's) stand was on abortion and how she would deal with cases to repeal Roe v. Wade. (I was also very ignorant about how the real world worked. I spouted what I was taught with passion and sincerity.) I was the only one who knew what an “ex-post facto” law was and my team won the Constitution Game because of my knowledge of the Constitution. (Literally, a staffer had to help the other two branches because Congress blew them out of the water.) (Both years!)
And, when I went and visited the 3rd year (I was unable to attend due to financial constraints –and more on that later) the whole alumni class asked that I be allowed to participate on their team. Their requests were turned down by the less-than-amused staffers.

I was completely gung-ho about TeenPact after my experience. I was effusive in my praise and I thought it was the best thing I had ever experienced and I wanted to attend ALL their other offerings.
Unfortunately, TeenPact is a rich, middle class thing. You pay your own way for everything. And “everything” is not cheap. You get an experience, the opportunity to meet friends, meals, and a T-Shirt. Often the events are far away and even staffers have to pay their own transportation. Housing is an extra cost on top of the $200-$300 event. (Unless it it its own event, like Endeavor or National Convention, which raised the price tag to $400 or more.)

   The first year I was in TeenPact I won a scholarship to go to National Convention and found a last-minute ride from Maryland. It was a 750-1000 word essay on “What Does it Mean to Be a Conservative.” Reading over it now it is a huge mess of right-wing idealism, including a rant about government distribution of wealth. Back then, I was so excited that I could hardly contain myself.

   I spent the week in a mix of pride, boredom, and frustrated anger. There was an obvious problem with popularity. The kids who had staffed multiple places had a huge edge over people who had staffed only their home state or not staffed at all. Their actual personalities were often sickening, but they still received the most votes and applause (or the elections were rigged in their favor). While there is a lot of discipleship and depth in the core groups, a lot of the event was fluffy and I was bored by the big speeches, only broken by the funny skits and attempts at making me play “The Game” (you just lost). Huge promotion of the Ultimate Frisbee tournaments annoyed me, as I was never that in to sports, and all attempts I made at throwing Frisbees resulted in everyone laughing and pointing. I would spend the afternoon wandering the camp looking for people in my group who might not be already with their cliques and might want to do something with me than gawk at Adam whats-his-name in a pink shirt playing with "The Bojangles."
   Because it was the first year that my state had ever had a TeenPact class, I was the only one from my state in attendance. I made a laughable attempt at running for Congress (and was one of the few late entries who actually paid my $10, to my knowledge). My contribution to much talked about and poorly attended silent auction was a necklace set that I hand-made.  It was made fun of for not having a more political or state relevance. (I think, I hid and refused to tell them that I made it)
   The only other person I found who was really a “kindred spirit” was a guy, and as I was not “allowed” to crush on him or spend any time with him without someone else there (I didn’t know anyone except staffers, and I followed the rules that I saw many of the “regulars” breaking) we never really got to know each other very well. Interestingly enough, he is the only one of any of them that I still keep in Facebook contact. And, through him I got to know a couple who are now some of my good friends.

   I came home from National Convention tired emotionally. I felt suddenly like TeenPact was not the marvelous place I had once thought it to be. I felt left out and unwanted by the very group I would have given my talents to willingly and eagerly. Unable to afford any other event that year, I began saving what little money I had in order to attend the State Class next year. I also applied to Staff, but I was turned down, which I almost expected. After all, I had spoken up and contradicted a staffer and made myself stick out. I paid for my alumni class all by myself, as my quiverfull father did not have the funds to spend on me for a second year. This is notable in that I was not allowed a job and made this money over the course of a year of saving odds and ends that came my way from neighborhood cleaning or babysitting jobs or from family members. I had no way to MAKE money, so spending that much meant a lot to me.
   I aced the alumni class, again proving to have put the most into the assignments and again leading my branch to victory in the Constitution Search. (When teams were picked everyone asked to switch to my team.) I made an effort to work my hardest and to not cause any issues. I was trying to prove myself as a competent person who was a good candidate to staff her own state. I was also at the upper age limit and I knew that this would be my last class.
    I wanted to attend Endeavor that year, but I was not able to make enough money and instead looked at the perfectly lit pictures of the other girls having a High Tea and shooting guns in a field thinking about how nice it would be to be able to have that kind of an experience. But their middle class families could afford the airfare or gas, the dresses, the makeup, the scones and high teas, and the price of the event.  My father made about $40,000 a year for a family of 11.



   The last year I spent in my home state I applied again to be a staffer and I was turned down again. One of my fellow classmates was accepted, though, as he had gone to National Convention and Survival. He also said that one of that year's staffers had pushed really hard for him. It figures, the staffer I had interrupted my first class was now an Intern (albeit he never came back to my state).
 

  Now, over 5 years later, I look back on it all with a sigh and a shake of my head. I was young and passionate. I had a lot to give and they turned it down. But in the end, I was the one better off for it. I left that state and have since been able to mediate my passion with real knowledge of the world and the incredible amount of variety and complexity in it. I no longer have “pat” answers to everything and I think I am all the better for it. I also refuse to accept their misogynistic belittling of women. I believe I have the right to wear a pair of dress pants instead of being relegated to a skirt. I think that I have just as much ability and knowledge as any male, as they refused to allow women to be an Intern for more than one year. Men could do it for two years and then if they excelled, they could go on to be a program director and have their own gavel made for them. I acknowledge that I could definitely be a Mayor or a President, which position they never elected a woman into. It was an interesting coincidence, if it really WAS a coincidence.
I refuse to think of myself less because I did not have the money that the “TeenPact Families” (ie. the blue bloods) had to host events and send their kids to staff 5 states and run expensive presidential campaigns with the paraphernalia, candy, and free T-shirts.


  I have saved only my first state class t-shirt with all the names on it. The names are mostly faded and can hardly be seen. I have de-friended most of the Interns (or been de-friended) and have since hidden most of my TeenPact pictures and videos. It is a chapter in my life that I do not regret, but do not like to announce. I prefer that no one remember me or pick me out as one of them. I regret being so conservative and blind. I do not regret getting away and changing.
And I hope that people who read this think twice about endorsing a misogynistic group that exists for the wealthy middle class republicans to indoctrinate their children. They also get together groups of students to do grunt work for HSLDA.  Read about that scandalous mess here.
 

November 25, 2012

Bit More Backstory:

My essay has almost 6,000 votes and I am awed and flabbergasted.
 I never expected that many people to know, or care, or want to help a stranger.

My past is a hard onion to unpeel. 
I was never outright denied and education, and I was never told I could never attend college.
But imagine being told day after day about how terrible public school is, and horror stories from your mother about her drunk and horny history teacher?  How would you feel about going to school then?
Or imagine reading multiple 'horror stories' about godly young people who were pulled astray while at secular and even some more liberal Christian Colleges?  (and my parents would also call that an oxymoron)

Imagine Mother Gothel's overly syrupy tone 'encouraging you' to always take a separate path from the world?  Telling you that you dont need a "scrap of paper" to tell people you are intelligent, well read, and have knowledge?

Yeah, that is the line I had to commit to memory.  "College is REALLY expensive.  And then, after spending around a quarter of a million dollars (yeah, that was the estimate I was told most often) and four to six years in a building, you get a piece of paper that tells the rest of the world you know something and can be hired."
(add a part about 4-year degrees taking about 5 or 6 years to complete being the average due to changing of majors, laziness in taking classes & failing, etc if you want to...)
"Why would you EVER want to do that?  I can go out there and buy any book I want. I can even get most of them from the Library.  Do I want to be a Botanist?  Get books out of the library and memorize plant's latin names.  Then plant and run a garden for a couple years.  Do I want to know everything about the Revolutionary War?  Again, read all the books you can find.  Go and visit key battlegrounds and cities where events took place.  By all means, learn and study and get and education!  But NOT at a college.  We can render them obsolete."
And this last one was a nice bundle of issues: "Fine, if you want a college degree, you can get an English degree at the local community college.  CLEP out of as much as you can, and only go in for one or two semesters (CollegePlus was always suggested).  Then, when the government takes away our right to homeschool you can file as a teacher and have your own school with your kids in it, and any unfortunate other homeschoolers who did not prepare their daughters in this way."


Now, one thing I can claim is that I did have an exemplary homeschooled education.  My mother had a college degree and she spent long hours making lesson plans and working out classes for us.  We were required to have 80% mastery of anything we were tested on.  If you did not, you would go back and study, do full corrections until you got everything right, and then re-take the test.
This applied for Math, the sciences, any written or oral tests she made up for history, and any English tests we came upon.  We did Saxon Math, so it was fairly easy to grade those by percent and have us re-do lessons.  Failing a test meant going back over all the practice of the lessons the test covered and re-taking the test.  In Wile Science, we re-did modules and the Quarterlies (I failed Chemistry a couple times) were made to re-do all the modules double-time.  (because we should have most of the information memorized)
I didnt fail much in English, but the essays were not given a percent.  Unless they had so much red that it was hard to see the essay, we didnt re-write those very much.
I loved reading and did a lot of that once I hit puberty and became embarrassed about my size.  Sitting on the couch curled up was a safe place for me where no one could see my hairy underarms (I wasnt allowed to shave for a while) or tease me for my curves.
I am a fast learner, my family calling me the one with the "mind like a steel trap."  I love History and I do well in English and writing. 

My younger siblings are not receiving the education I did, because there are more little kids to care for, because we older siblings arent around to take care of a lot of the house duties and because my mother is much older and much more worn down than she was teaching the 'first round.'
  Also, I am seeing significant (sometimes purposeful) gaps in her current methods of teaching now that I am out in the world and finding out how reality differs from the family bubble...

To Be Continued.....

October 1, 2010

Staring contest

So here I am doing my work, and into the store walks a quintent of jean-skirted, large-sized-t-shirted, sneaker wearing, hair-in-a-bun women.

I am in my black jeans, fitting long-sleeved shirt, and makeup, and my hair in a design.

I could probably help it, but I stare at them. I have this crazy urge to follow them around the store and listen to how they talk to one-another. I want to see if they rode a big car here. I want them to come by me, but they check out behind my line of vision. At one point I broke from my training and turned around and caught one of the girls eyes. It was amazing. I could see the self-righteous pity oozing out of them. Me in my feminism-bound working nightmare. Me in my worldly blindness, them the only holy light in my world. I don't know, maybe I was imagining it.

I turned back to what I was doing, waiting for the rush of guilt. I always used to get it when I was around someone more "modestly dressed" than I was.

Nothing

I felt nothing.

I turned around again, and this time all three of the daughters (the two ladies were older, and had the money) were looking at me. A different girl was looking at me with a hint of scorn, I think. I panned over to the moms. The one looked at me and smiled kindly. I turned around again and focused on my work.


Next time I looked around they were gone.

March 5, 2010

Defrauding Daughters:

Prelude: This is one of my first attempts at vocalizing some of the issues that boiled within me. Written 2-11-2010



Scripture is clear that defrauding is a sin. It also clearly states that provoking to wrath is equally as serious as disobedience to God-placed authority. (For the purposes of clarity: I am defining defrauding and provoking-to-wrath synonymously)

Why then am I applying this to daughters? I shall explain.

There is a large movement (I am tempted to say “in the homeschooling community”, but it might have spread farther, so I shall not limit it to my knowledge) of families in which the daughters are given a life goal from the moment they are born (or known to be female, in this modern age of ultrasound).
This goal is to marry and be a mother. In most families it is laden with Biblical background and blessing, and placed before young women as the only non-sinful path for their pure feet to tread.
While I do not want to take away from the great office of any wife or mother, I beg to differ from this so-deemed golden rule for daughters. Why? Because it sets them up for defrauding, being provoked to wrath, and internal warfare for the entirety of their single life.
Think about it this way: The different parts of a person mature at different rates. A woman is physically capable of having children much younger than most people today would consider a suitable age for marriage. One's soul and spirit also mature differently depending on personal maturity and how much each is fed.*
When a daughter is PHYSICALLY ready to marry may or may not be when she is EMOTIONALLY ready---. Whether or not she is SPIRITUALLY stable in her walk with God is another matter altogether. Thus, a young girl of 16 is “ready to marry” (physically) but will probably not be married for another (at least) 3 or so years. A girl of (well, I am extremely hesitant to put a number here) on up may be “ready to marry” (emotionally) but will surely not be married for approx. 10 or more years. (Some very young girls have already decided on a future husband!)
As far as spiritual maturity, it can only be gauged by the young woman, or between herself and God. She needs to be fully reliant on God, and be walking closer to Him than any other person in her life before she can be able to serve a husband.

Yet, young women are expected to not “want” to get married. They are reprimanded (or at least it is frowned upon) for thinking about boys, or (all heaven forbid) “picking out” one they would prefer above any other.** Their state of “emotional purity” is to be of their utmost concern (which would be sullied by even allowing a thought like “He is soooo handsome” float across their minds). Verses from Song of Solomon (You may laugh now) are used to apply to single young women (you may laugh even harder) to encourage them in such aims (rolling on the floor in helpless guffaws is also permissible).

Thus, a young woman who is looking to fulfill the life's calling to which she has been encouraged her entire life (yes, even from the womb!!) is told to stop thinking about marriage, to not look at a boy more than once, to not “awaken love” (ie. want to get married [wait? Isn't that what they are supposed to want?]), and not to set their hearts on getting married. (“There may be an isolated chance that no man would come along until you are 27, or 30, or even 40, or maybe even never....hmmm...”)
Then there is a whole industry that writes book about what young women in such predicaments (wait, did I just use that word?) could do with their time and efforts (while still waiting to find a husband, but not wanting one—that would be sin).

Therefore, I would say that this is provoking-to-wrath and defrauding. There is nothing more provoking than to be told to do something, and then told not to want to do it. It does not even make any logical sense!!! If wanting to be married is a bad thing (discontent, emotionally impure, etc) than why would anyone be raised with marriage as their end goal in life? As the purpose for which they were created by God? As the one truly perfect career for a woman? As the only possible non-sinful career they could pick?
It is defrauding in that a young woman is constantly at war with the physical part of her (biological clock?) and/or the emotional which is “ready” but she is not of an age wherein marriage is considered (or perhaps family has decreed a number, or there are no “perfect” young men available). It is natural for a woman to want companionship, to want to be sought after, and to want to be cherished. Marriage and the family are God-ordained, and thus good things to be desired. However, when we make this a sin, or when we discourage girls from spending time and effort in this area they can quickly get smothered in despair.

It is illogical to encourage a girl to something her entire life, and then when she is ready (or partly read) she is rebuked for thinking/speaking in such a way/wanting such things.
It is defrauding to them to build up their hopes with prayers for “a man of God to come along and marry ______ someday...” and then frighten her to emotional sterility with the spectre of “emotional purity”.
It is provoking to wrath to encourage a girls to prepare for marriage mentally, and then tell them that mental energy spent thinking about (I'm gonna say it: BOYS!!!) marriage/husband/future may be a sin.




*I am leaving mental knowledge/capability out of this list because it varies from family to family on the list of “required before Betsy is allowed to' ______'”. Does it include baking perfect homemade bread? Or just a Cherry pie that will make Billy-boy's mouth water? Thus I find it would be cumbersome to discuss and would bog down the point of this post with arbitrary homemaking skills*

**I am not by any means challenging that a woman cannot initiate a marriage offer, or going into a dissertation that women should not be responders, or that women should be initiators. I am merely pointing out some of the things that go through young-girls-who-would-like-to-be-married-some-day's minds that are considered improper or sinful.