Reading over the BJU Investigation Final Report by GRACE today I was particularly struck by the part of how Matthew 18 does or does not apply to cases like sexual abuse.
As someone who has been victimized in other ways, many people have pushed Matthew 18 in my face with less than any grace as if I cannot speak about what I have endured or the things I suffered until I follow their rules for me.
(And no, while Matt 18 may be a biblical rule for conflict resolution, making it a requirement before someone speaks publicly is a personal rule that you are putting on another person over whom you have no right to put rules.)
I remembered, during my reading, a rather traumatic event in my teenage-hood where a semblance of Matthew 18 happened. Like all flashbacks of my traumas, this is a memory captured in a picture frame, everything crystal clear and piled in emotion, the faces and words of people hanging in the air as the scene plays out in one still life painting...
During one of our home-church sessions with the only like-minded family that my father could find to agree with his bajillion rules (and even so they disagreed on things like headcoverings and speaking in church... somehow those werent so bad all the sudden?) my brother somehow got up the nerve to confront my father about his past actions and his lack of repentance for them as evidenced by his comportment around people and how he acted to his family and children.
Like he always does, my father argued that his role as head was divine right and that no matter what serious sins he committed in the past (less than 3 years ago), he had definitely repented and no longer needed to act like he was repenting. He was free to be the patriarch as was his right.
Slowly, my mother and older sister and myself joined in the conversation, truly sharing our hearts and crying, all of us in tears, except my mother who sat stone-faced in the corner. She shared the least of all of us, my thought is that her pain had reached the point where tears didnt even help any more. My big brother with tears streaming down his face, the instigator of this confrontation, sat with his back to kitchen, glaring angrily at my father through his pain, hurt, and finally letting out the magma that had been seething for years. My older sister sat closest to me and my mother. She had found a way out, and was planning an escape. She contributed only when the emotion in the room reached maximum levels. And then there was me. I sat looking alternately out at the dismal ice-scratched face of central PA through the lace curtains, and around at the room. I had the foolish hope that this confrontation would mean something, that somehow our hearts and tears would result in the overthrow of the spell that the Pied Piper of patriarchy had put on our "head."
First my brother, then the rest of us adult children (I was the youngest at 18 and a couple months), and briefly my mother reiterated the problems we had with how my father conducted himself as a commiter of serious sin. Finally, the discussion included the father of the other family we met with that Sunday afternoon... the other "pastor," the only one allowed to talk in his family, the only other part of our "church."
And this is when the partiarchy overwhelmed Matthew 18. Because they dont work together. Because like oil and water, like bleach and a stain, one must win and one must submit or get the thread it clings to burned into disintegration. The other patriarch scolded all of us, including our mother, for doubting my father's testimony on his own behalf.
Obviously we were all bitter and had refused to forgive our father. We were not being the proper subjects to his god-appointed ruling. The other patriarch's earnest, pale face and shiny bald head turned mostly towards my older brother as the instigator, I see him sitting comfortably close to my father, at times reaching out a caring hand to touch my father on the shoulder as emphasis for what a stellar patriarch my father was. My mother retreated further into the corner, I think if she could have turned green she would have faded into the pale sage of the walls. My older sister left the room shaking her head at the pointlessness of it all. My brother clenched his fist and his face turned bright red, anger coursing through him as he looked like once again he had been beaten/spanked as he was as a child.
I dont remember my own reaction, but inside another part of me shriveled up and died. It was pointless fighting against the patriarchs. Of course we were in the wrong, of course we had not truly forgiven. After all, what can stand against the combined wisdom and headship of god's appointed heads? I remember driving home feeling more suicidal than before, if that was possible. My father was not held to repentance or required to act like he needed to make amends.
He would often tell me that he was owed respect and that he had no need to earn it, and then this situation only perpetuated his superiority. We bowed and kissed the boot that stepped on our backs.
Fast forward less than a year later, maybe even as little as 6 months, my oldest sister found a way out and ran away from home in the middle of the night. I looked into her eyes 2 days before this and saw something that took the breath away from me. I knew that she needed to leave, or she would die. Still suffering from Stockholm Syndrome, I realized that nothing I believed in mattered as much as my oldest sister's life. I disobeyed all my parent's beliefs and helped her escape.
Not knowing my involvement, my parents feared that I might be influenced by my sister's "rebellion" and decided to send me to Bill Gothard's Journey To The Heart in Northwoods. This was a prodigious expense for my poverty-level parents, but they made it happen in order to "save" me from the same future.
As I was packing, my mother asked me to speak to Mr. G in a re-attempt of the final step of Matthew 18. Her exact words were "He is the last man your father respects and who can hold him accountable." Although I had to fight to get a personal audience with G, I attempted to help my mother, my family, and myself as well, still unaware of the contrary nature of patriarchy and biblical accountability.
G took the usual course and told me to find the sin in myself and to write down the things I was grateful for that my parents had taught me. Instead of seeing this as the last-ditch attempt of a family to seek biblical resolution for a serious sin, he turned on me like a patriarch, defending his own, and demanded that I once again submit myself to patriarchal rules.
I left in tears, ashamed of myself, because that is how he wanted me to feel.
Fast forward to today:
While I think that scripture has some significantly good things to teach us, I think that the first thing that needs to be demolished is patriarchy. Like the Eye of Sauron, it permeates all corners of the Fundamentalist Conservative Worldview, and opposes any attempts at dissent, even though it is a cruel, evil, and twisted power. Patriarchy will not allow Matthew 18 to work against themselves, and therefore they render it useless. Any other biblical passages you bring up will also be shot down. There is no accountability or reason allowed when it comes to men. Sin and impurity and even abuse will be allowed as long as they can keep up their "good old boys" club, and they will send the women and children through pain and torture as long as they remain in power.
SMASH THE PATRIARCHY!!!!!!!
Out of a cult and towards reality
Welcome!
Aliases become me.
I am DoaHF, and Jennifer, and a couple other names.
This was once the Defrauded Daughters blog, but the name and url had to be changed because my parents found it and were reading and using it against me.
Read, comment, and leave thinking.
I am honored you came to visit.
I am DoaHF, and Jennifer, and a couple other names.
This was once the Defrauded Daughters blog, but the name and url had to be changed because my parents found it and were reading and using it against me.
Read, comment, and leave thinking.
I am honored you came to visit.
Showing posts with label Gothard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gothard. Show all posts
December 11, 2014
Matthew 18 vs Patriarchy
Labels:
abuse,
altercations,
Bible,
church,
family,
Gothard,
memories,
mothers,
patriarchy,
rejection
November 6, 2014
Lemony HSLDA Snicket
This evening I watched the 2004 "Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events."
I found it both endearing and triggering, but I laughed out loud at the odd combination of pop-culture ( Osh Kosh B'Gosh), the grammar nazi, and steampunk clothing and machinery.
I almost cried when the children see in the letter that they are all they have. I know how it feels to be the only one looking out for your siblings and feeling like the ONLY one who really loves them and looks out for their futures.
But the parts that made me upset were the parallels to what is going on right now in 2014.
When Violet reminds her brother about their parents trip to Europe I was upset by the fact that not only would the parents not tell the children, but the "letter that got lost" sounds just like what rich, unattached parents would say as an excuse.
Go ahead and call me cynical. I have been hurt one too many times to trust very easily.
But the part that made the blogging fire blaze in my soul, was the ending, where the watching crowd gasps at "Count Olaf's" reveal of his plan and behavior, and the fact that he had just legally married the 14 year old to which he had been given custody.
Despite the children seeing through his outward veneer, and attempting to advise and warn the adults in their lives, they are consistently shut down and repeatedly ignored as the adult is manipulated by Count Olaf.
Much like HSLDA, Michael Farris, Karen Campbell, Heidi St. John, and Voddie Baucham have been grooming the adults in the homeschooling world, only a couple "Count Olafs" have been unveiled: namely Doug Phillips and his flagship Vision Forum, and Gothard with his IBLP banner.
Ignoring the parallels of a society where Phil Robertson of Duck Dynasty can support and encourage child marriage and still be respected, these big fish in the homeschooling pond are consistently being taken in by predators, or are the predators themselves in disguise. When "children" (as some people keep calling us, despite our age) call out the problems that they see, the abuse, the misuse of power, the blatant evil in the waters, we are ignored and shut down.
Repeatedly.
How long will it take for the villain to finally feel so comfortable that his mask will slip and the "well meaning" banker and the buffoon of a detective realize that in all their time being #notyourhomeschoolpolice, they have only handed over the victims to their abusers again and again?!?
How long will it take before the voices of the children are listened to?
How long before the "well-meaning" leaders of the movement TAKE AN HONEST LOOK AT THEMSELVES and see that they are ACCOMPLICES to all the evil that has been going on, and to all the evil that WILL CONTINUE to happen.
EVIL
EVIL
EVIL
I dont know how many times I have to say it before they hear me.
I dont know how long it will take for something to change
I dont know what else to do in a community that is already distrusted and cast-out.
But we are family, homeschool survivors. We will always have eachother, we will always know the truth and know that we did not stand idly by and be accomplices ourselves.
As Lemony Snicket says:
I am no inventor. I may only be able to bite at the heels of these big fish, and babble my go-go's and ga-ga's at them.... but I promise to bite as hard as I can to make a sanctuary for all of us.
I found it both endearing and triggering, but I laughed out loud at the odd combination of pop-culture ( Osh Kosh B'Gosh), the grammar nazi, and steampunk clothing and machinery.
I almost cried when the children see in the letter that they are all they have. I know how it feels to be the only one looking out for your siblings and feeling like the ONLY one who really loves them and looks out for their futures.
But the parts that made me upset were the parallels to what is going on right now in 2014.
When Violet reminds her brother about their parents trip to Europe I was upset by the fact that not only would the parents not tell the children, but the "letter that got lost" sounds just like what rich, unattached parents would say as an excuse.
Go ahead and call me cynical. I have been hurt one too many times to trust very easily.
But the part that made the blogging fire blaze in my soul, was the ending, where the watching crowd gasps at "Count Olaf's" reveal of his plan and behavior, and the fact that he had just legally married the 14 year old to which he had been given custody.
"I'm the monster? You're the monster! These children tried to warn you, but you wouldn't listen. No one ever listens to children!"
Despite the children seeing through his outward veneer, and attempting to advise and warn the adults in their lives, they are consistently shut down and repeatedly ignored as the adult is manipulated by Count Olaf.
Much like HSLDA, Michael Farris, Karen Campbell, Heidi St. John, and Voddie Baucham have been grooming the adults in the homeschooling world, only a couple "Count Olafs" have been unveiled: namely Doug Phillips and his flagship Vision Forum, and Gothard with his IBLP banner.
Ignoring the parallels of a society where Phil Robertson of Duck Dynasty can support and encourage child marriage and still be respected, these big fish in the homeschooling pond are consistently being taken in by predators, or are the predators themselves in disguise. When "children" (as some people keep calling us, despite our age) call out the problems that they see, the abuse, the misuse of power, the blatant evil in the waters, we are ignored and shut down.
Repeatedly.
How long will it take for the villain to finally feel so comfortable that his mask will slip and the "well meaning" banker and the buffoon of a detective realize that in all their time being #notyourhomeschoolpolice, they have only handed over the victims to their abusers again and again?!?
How long will it take before the voices of the children are listened to?
How long before the "well-meaning" leaders of the movement TAKE AN HONEST LOOK AT THEMSELVES and see that they are ACCOMPLICES to all the evil that has been going on, and to all the evil that WILL CONTINUE to happen.
EVIL
EVIL
EVIL
I dont know how many times I have to say it before they hear me.
I dont know how long it will take for something to change
I dont know what else to do in a community that is already distrusted and cast-out.
But we are family, homeschool survivors. We will always have eachother, we will always know the truth and know that we did not stand idly by and be accomplices ourselves.
As Lemony Snicket says:
And they are the sort of people who know that there's always something. Something to invent, something to read, something to bite, and something to do, to make a sanctuary, no matter how small.
I am no inventor. I may only be able to bite at the heels of these big fish, and babble my go-go's and ga-ga's at them.... but I promise to bite as hard as I can to make a sanctuary for all of us.
Labels:
abuse,
defrauding,
fear,
Gothard,
patriarchy,
people,
quotes,
shame
October 28, 2014
Gothard, again
You blamed me and some supposed, hidden sin in my life rather than the blatant woeful treatment I’d been receiving.
Once again, you held me responsible for the abuses of others.
~Heather
I wrote a long letter to most of the members of my family about two weeks ago because I know that they are still keeping Gothard materials in their homes and even using them for their own "enrichment" or for teaching my siblings.
I told them about how I got the famed "personal interview" with Got-hard and how he immediately closed down the conversation and the time when I said that our missionary family had not been able to afford to purchase and ship his homeschooling and other materials overseas.
I told them about the second time we talked when I came to him with a special request from my mother. Desperate for "godly" solutions to our increasing home trauma, she asked me to ask G to call and counsel my father. As she put it, G was one of the last teachers on earth who my father respected and would listen to.
Instead of listening to me he attached the blame to me. He said I must be bitter and had me do a writing assignment. Then he left for a long period of time ostensibly to talk to some delegate in mexico on a "gospel-spreading mission." When he finally deigned to come back and speak with me, he looked quickly over my pages of writing and again ordered me to asses myself on my own time, and write further because obviously the first draft was half-heartedly done and did not really reach the depths of my bitter, hardened heart. Why else would I dare question the behavior of my father, no matter how many times I attempted to reiterate that it was my mother's request with which she entrusted me.
After both times I left his office sobbing deeply and felt not only valueless, but dirty and shamed. How could this great "seer" (as my Journey Leader Libby called him) have possibly gotten my situation wrong? He was the one who was the leader and I was one of the inductees.
I told them in the email about how one girl who was largely deaf, but with golden hair and big blue eyes was asked to stay. Another girl, one of a twin, was asked to stay the last day. Her other twin was more loud, "tomboyish" (in the most feminine sense of the word), and had darker hair and more makeup was left protesting. She was told that she had to go home and finish school, while her mostly identical twin got showered with the honor of being asked to stay at HQ. (Her school was somehow able to be completed via distance at OakBrook)
When I contacted my mother by phone (a twice-a-year-if-that-occurrence) a week or so after, I mentioned the email to her and she voiced extreme reticence to not only believe the accusations, but to see G's horrendous teachings for what they were. She felt that the testimonies were hearsay and few and far between and did not compromise his lectures and seminars.
She did not discount my story, but she apologized for putting such an expectation on a 19-year old. I told her that I felt proud to be her emissary and was deeply disappointed that I was not able to help my family. And then I told her something that nagged at me then like a mosquito bite and was obvious to me now: I KNEW that I WAS NOT THE REASON that there were problems in our family. Yet I was made to feel responsible because of how G acted and the very pointed things he said, almost in those exact words, that I was.
Making children responsible for the sins of their families is heresy. In fact, it is also abusive, cruel, and harmful to the children/adults themselves.
I think this is something that has yet to be fully addressed by places that focus more on g's theology. But I know that it has been a constant thread for those of us with family.
Once again, you held me responsible for the abuses of others.
~Heather
I wrote a long letter to most of the members of my family about two weeks ago because I know that they are still keeping Gothard materials in their homes and even using them for their own "enrichment" or for teaching my siblings.
I told them about how I got the famed "personal interview" with Got-hard and how he immediately closed down the conversation and the time when I said that our missionary family had not been able to afford to purchase and ship his homeschooling and other materials overseas.
I told them about the second time we talked when I came to him with a special request from my mother. Desperate for "godly" solutions to our increasing home trauma, she asked me to ask G to call and counsel my father. As she put it, G was one of the last teachers on earth who my father respected and would listen to.
Instead of listening to me he attached the blame to me. He said I must be bitter and had me do a writing assignment. Then he left for a long period of time ostensibly to talk to some delegate in mexico on a "gospel-spreading mission." When he finally deigned to come back and speak with me, he looked quickly over my pages of writing and again ordered me to asses myself on my own time, and write further because obviously the first draft was half-heartedly done and did not really reach the depths of my bitter, hardened heart. Why else would I dare question the behavior of my father, no matter how many times I attempted to reiterate that it was my mother's request with which she entrusted me.
After both times I left his office sobbing deeply and felt not only valueless, but dirty and shamed. How could this great "seer" (as my Journey Leader Libby called him) have possibly gotten my situation wrong? He was the one who was the leader and I was one of the inductees.
I told them in the email about how one girl who was largely deaf, but with golden hair and big blue eyes was asked to stay. Another girl, one of a twin, was asked to stay the last day. Her other twin was more loud, "tomboyish" (in the most feminine sense of the word), and had darker hair and more makeup was left protesting. She was told that she had to go home and finish school, while her mostly identical twin got showered with the honor of being asked to stay at HQ. (Her school was somehow able to be completed via distance at OakBrook)
When I contacted my mother by phone (a twice-a-year-if-that-occurrence) a week or so after, I mentioned the email to her and she voiced extreme reticence to not only believe the accusations, but to see G's horrendous teachings for what they were. She felt that the testimonies were hearsay and few and far between and did not compromise his lectures and seminars.
She did not discount my story, but she apologized for putting such an expectation on a 19-year old. I told her that I felt proud to be her emissary and was deeply disappointed that I was not able to help my family. And then I told her something that nagged at me then like a mosquito bite and was obvious to me now: I KNEW that I WAS NOT THE REASON that there were problems in our family. Yet I was made to feel responsible because of how G acted and the very pointed things he said, almost in those exact words, that I was.
Making children responsible for the sins of their families is heresy. In fact, it is also abusive, cruel, and harmful to the children/adults themselves.
I think this is something that has yet to be fully addressed by places that focus more on g's theology. But I know that it has been a constant thread for those of us with family.
Labels:
abuse,
altercations,
Gothard,
patriarchy,
rejection,
scripture manipulation,
shame
October 9, 2014
This is How We Do
HEY Homeschooling Parents!!
Did you know that Katy Perry was the daughter of a pastor?
How do you think her father/mother raised her was any different from how you raised your kids?
(Whatever you are thinking, its probably wrong)
Her message in this catchy dance-song is that life for the new generation of young adults (that she is one of) is a lot different from other lifestyles that came before. But this different life is normal and works for them. Its just what they DO.
Do you remember how you raised us?
Your arrows in your quiver?
Your future warriors?
Your young Joshua generation?
Yet some of us are speaking out and you arent very happy about it. There are closet-skeletons being laid out to air. There are great leaders toppling left and right. There are rugs being pulled back and all the grime under them being exposed to the light.
And the question that most parents I hear from ask is this: "Why are you chipping away at the very movement that created you?"
Because.
THIS. IS. HOW. WE. DO
We were raised to change the culture for the better.
We were raised to have loud voices against evil.
We were raised to not back down and to never stop
FIGHTING for what is right.
We were trained to not be ashamed of our youth.
We were trained to stand up to authorities without fear.
We were required to use and work with logic and truth daily.
We had to be of sound and strong mind.
We needed to go out and challenge the status quo...
At least that is what YOU TAUGHT US.
This is how we do, straight pulling down ivory
towers of the home school elite.
This is how we do, do, do, do, do
This is how we do.
Standing up for truth and openness.
Fighting against sin and hidden evil.
Exposing the liars and the dirty, dirty cheats.
Refusing to stop on our quest for change.
Because you taught us well.
And this is how we do. Our kind of life is different, but to us, it is normal and just something we were raised to DO.
November 25, 2012
Bit More Backstory:
My essay has almost 6,000 votes and I am awed and flabbergasted.
I never expected that many people to know, or care, or want to help a stranger.
My past is a hard onion to unpeel.
I was never outright denied and education, and I was never told I could never attend college.
But imagine being told day after day about how terrible public school is, and horror stories from your mother about her drunk and horny history teacher? How would you feel about going to school then?
Or imagine reading multiple 'horror stories' about godly young people who were pulled astray while at secular and even some more liberal Christian Colleges? (and my parents would also call that an oxymoron)
Imagine Mother Gothel's overly syrupy tone 'encouraging you' to always take a separate path from the world? Telling you that you dont need a "scrap of paper" to tell people you are intelligent, well read, and have knowledge?
Yeah, that is the line I had to commit to memory. "College is REALLY expensive. And then, after spending around a quarter of a million dollars (yeah, that was the estimate I was told most often) and four to six years in a building, you get a piece of paper that tells the rest of the world you know something and can be hired."
(add a part about 4-year degrees taking about 5 or 6 years to complete being the average due to changing of majors, laziness in taking classes & failing, etc if you want to...)
"Why would you EVER want to do that? I can go out there and buy any book I want. I can even get most of them from the Library. Do I want to be a Botanist? Get books out of the library and memorize plant's latin names. Then plant and run a garden for a couple years. Do I want to know everything about the Revolutionary War? Again, read all the books you can find. Go and visit key battlegrounds and cities where events took place. By all means, learn and study and get and education! But NOT at a college. We can render them obsolete."
And this last one was a nice bundle of issues: "Fine, if you want a college degree, you can get an English degree at the local community college. CLEP out of as much as you can, and only go in for one or two semesters (CollegePlus was always suggested). Then, when the government takes away our right to homeschool you can file as a teacher and have your own school with your kids in it, and any unfortunate other homeschoolers who did not prepare their daughters in this way."
Now, one thing I can claim is that I did have an exemplary homeschooled education. My mother had a college degree and she spent long hours making lesson plans and working out classes for us. We were required to have 80% mastery of anything we were tested on. If you did not, you would go back and study, do full corrections until you got everything right, and then re-take the test.
This applied for Math, the sciences, any written or oral tests she made up for history, and any English tests we came upon. We did Saxon Math, so it was fairly easy to grade those by percent and have us re-do lessons. Failing a test meant going back over all the practice of the lessons the test covered and re-taking the test. In Wile Science, we re-did modules and the Quarterlies (I failed Chemistry a couple times) were made to re-do all the modules double-time. (because we should have most of the information memorized)
I didnt fail much in English, but the essays were not given a percent. Unless they had so much red that it was hard to see the essay, we didnt re-write those very much.
I loved reading and did a lot of that once I hit puberty and became embarrassed about my size. Sitting on the couch curled up was a safe place for me where no one could see my hairy underarms (I wasnt allowed to shave for a while) or tease me for my curves.
I am a fast learner, my family calling me the one with the "mind like a steel trap." I love History and I do well in English and writing.
My younger siblings are not receiving the education I did, because there are more little kids to care for, because we older siblings arent around to take care of a lot of the house duties and because my mother is much older and much more worn down than she was teaching the 'first round.'
Also, I am seeing significant (sometimes purposeful) gaps in her current methods of teaching now that I am out in the world and finding out how reality differs from the family bubble...
To Be Continued.....
I never expected that many people to know, or care, or want to help a stranger.
My past is a hard onion to unpeel.
I was never outright denied and education, and I was never told I could never attend college.
But imagine being told day after day about how terrible public school is, and horror stories from your mother about her drunk and horny history teacher? How would you feel about going to school then?
Or imagine reading multiple 'horror stories' about godly young people who were pulled astray while at secular and even some more liberal Christian Colleges? (and my parents would also call that an oxymoron)
Imagine Mother Gothel's overly syrupy tone 'encouraging you' to always take a separate path from the world? Telling you that you dont need a "scrap of paper" to tell people you are intelligent, well read, and have knowledge?
Yeah, that is the line I had to commit to memory. "College is REALLY expensive. And then, after spending around a quarter of a million dollars (yeah, that was the estimate I was told most often) and four to six years in a building, you get a piece of paper that tells the rest of the world you know something and can be hired."
(add a part about 4-year degrees taking about 5 or 6 years to complete being the average due to changing of majors, laziness in taking classes & failing, etc if you want to...)
"Why would you EVER want to do that? I can go out there and buy any book I want. I can even get most of them from the Library. Do I want to be a Botanist? Get books out of the library and memorize plant's latin names. Then plant and run a garden for a couple years. Do I want to know everything about the Revolutionary War? Again, read all the books you can find. Go and visit key battlegrounds and cities where events took place. By all means, learn and study and get and education! But NOT at a college. We can render them obsolete."
And this last one was a nice bundle of issues: "Fine, if you want a college degree, you can get an English degree at the local community college. CLEP out of as much as you can, and only go in for one or two semesters (CollegePlus was always suggested). Then, when the government takes away our right to homeschool you can file as a teacher and have your own school with your kids in it, and any unfortunate other homeschoolers who did not prepare their daughters in this way."
Now, one thing I can claim is that I did have an exemplary homeschooled education. My mother had a college degree and she spent long hours making lesson plans and working out classes for us. We were required to have 80% mastery of anything we were tested on. If you did not, you would go back and study, do full corrections until you got everything right, and then re-take the test.
This applied for Math, the sciences, any written or oral tests she made up for history, and any English tests we came upon. We did Saxon Math, so it was fairly easy to grade those by percent and have us re-do lessons. Failing a test meant going back over all the practice of the lessons the test covered and re-taking the test. In Wile Science, we re-did modules and the Quarterlies (I failed Chemistry a couple times) were made to re-do all the modules double-time. (because we should have most of the information memorized)
I didnt fail much in English, but the essays were not given a percent. Unless they had so much red that it was hard to see the essay, we didnt re-write those very much.
I loved reading and did a lot of that once I hit puberty and became embarrassed about my size. Sitting on the couch curled up was a safe place for me where no one could see my hairy underarms (I wasnt allowed to shave for a while) or tease me for my curves.
I am a fast learner, my family calling me the one with the "mind like a steel trap." I love History and I do well in English and writing.
My younger siblings are not receiving the education I did, because there are more little kids to care for, because we older siblings arent around to take care of a lot of the house duties and because my mother is much older and much more worn down than she was teaching the 'first round.'
Also, I am seeing significant (sometimes purposeful) gaps in her current methods of teaching now that I am out in the world and finding out how reality differs from the family bubble...
To Be Continued.....
May 6, 2011
Broken
I feel so broken right now.
I woke up today with a song and a Bible verse floating around in my head. The song is a 'meh' song by a rather old (80's) CCM singer who is popular in the third-world country where I grew up in. I had to laugh when I looked up the song on youtube, all the videos were karaoke dubs from that nation.
Anyway, the verse was: "God is near to the broken hearted."
I tried looking for it, and after a couple unsuccessful tries, I found it in Psalm 34:18.
I read the verse and sighed, because God was still out to get me to return home to my parents and be a good daughter.
Then I got mad. I had given God a rest for a while. Not 'gone to church', not read Daddy's NKJV version, not even allowed myself to read the tracts people keep handing me at work. I was hoping space and distance would heal something and let me be a 'good' christian like I was raised to be. *insert meek and quiet smile.
But after a break of about ten minutes I looked over a different version of it because sometimes it helps me take the verse out of preconditioned-reading-mode; which is what I needed.
I suddenly realized that no one else would get my first reaction out of the verse. Then I began picking myself apart like I always do trying to figure out why I thought that in the first place, and how to change, and berating myself for still thinking the way I used to think. Gah.
And while picking apart myself; this is what I heard:
My bible-reader is broken and my brain is broken and I cant do this.
I woke up today with a song and a Bible verse floating around in my head. The song is a 'meh' song by a rather old (80's) CCM singer who is popular in the third-world country where I grew up in. I had to laugh when I looked up the song on youtube, all the videos were karaoke dubs from that nation.
Anyway, the verse was: "God is near to the broken hearted."
I tried looking for it, and after a couple unsuccessful tries, I found it in Psalm 34:18.
I read the verse and sighed, because God was still out to get me to return home to my parents and be a good daughter.
Then I got mad. I had given God a rest for a while. Not 'gone to church', not read Daddy's NKJV version, not even allowed myself to read the tracts people keep handing me at work. I was hoping space and distance would heal something and let me be a 'good' christian like I was raised to be. *insert meek and quiet smile.
But after a break of about ten minutes I looked over a different version of it because sometimes it helps me take the verse out of preconditioned-reading-mode; which is what I needed.
I suddenly realized that no one else would get my first reaction out of the verse. Then I began picking myself apart like I always do trying to figure out why I thought that in the first place, and how to change, and berating myself for still thinking the way I used to think. Gah.
And while picking apart myself; this is what I heard:
The first verse is all hellfire and damnation. Just look at it. If a sermon is preached about it where will the bulk of the message lay: the second part. "Such as have a contrite heart." Obviously, the first thing that sticks out is the huge condition. 'Only the certain honest/blessed/perfect individuals who REALLY have a contrite heart.' Only those who God has searched and interrogated and picked apart to find no wrong motives in. Only such as those. Like: only those with the heart of a child. Only the REALLY contrite.And that is when I started crying and decided to not read the Bible anymore for another long while.
And then there is the 'contrite.' Sheesh, only a KJV-er would understand that. Contrite is like what they did to enemies in Bible times. Made them walk under a small doorway in front of the conquering general. They would have to get down low and possibly on their knees and squeeze through this door (the eye of a needle, anyone?) and humble themselves. And, because God knows your heart, he is not the overbearing general who only looks at the outside obeisance. He sees your HEART too, and your HEART is wicked and before you dare ask Him to be there for you, or be near to your sadness and weakness? You better have it cleaned out of all the bad things and made truly pure and honest before you do such a thing.
In short: You, missy, are so, so, SO far from the qualifier on this verse and SO far from being able to accomplish it that there is no way God could (even if he wanted to, because we all know that God cant abide sin and evil) come near you or even pay attention to your brokenness. Nu-uh. Not gonna happen.
My bible-reader is broken and my brain is broken and I cant do this.
Labels:
abuse,
Bible,
church,
defrauding,
Gothard,
patriarchy,
rejection,
scripture manipulation,
shame
March 6, 2010
A Testimony
This post is a very hesitant one for me.
I know that there are a lot of “Gothard survivors” out there, and I empathize with them deeply.
My father went to his first Gothard seminar as a young man. He said it affected him profoundly, and he took my mother to one when they were still dating. She latched on to it as well, and in our house the 3 volume “Character Sketches” tomes were on hand as a resource....
But we rarely ever used them.
Despite the good things they liked about Gothard, my parents never ended up joining ATI or have gone beyond attending Advanced and Anger Resolution Seminars. However, my father did use “youth conflicts” materials as a basis for a “Principles for Progress in Life” (PPL) seminar he used for a while where we were missionaries. After a while, when he had established a reputation in the community and had a handful of converts, he moved into more of a discipleship program than a salvation one, and PPL digressed to the annals of our history.
However, admiration for Gothard has remained strong, and lately my mother has been using the Character Sketches books more for their Bible stories and picture worth.
I attended Basic when I was 15, after we moved to the States for good. I think I did advanced, but I don't remember when, and I did Anger Resolution just a few years ago. (2007, I think)
I respected Mr Gothard for the scripture in what he taught and because my parents looked up to him as a great Bible Scholar and teacher.
So, when I was out looking for a place to “get away” I was not very surprised when my father pulled up the ponderous list of ATI alumni activities. I had set my heart on attending TeenPact's Endeavor, but due to money constraints, I did not register soon enough, and I would be down about 15 on the waiting list. So, my father encouraged me to look elsewhere.
Journey to the Heart stuck out to me because it was near Chicago (I have always liked that city for some reason), because I could visit friends out in that area while I was out there (another reason for liking the city), and because it promised me a whole new walk with God. I had come through a lot on the plane that separates stagnation and passion, and I could never seem to find balance.
Saved as a young child, living as a Christian meant little to me. As I hit the double digits all I wanted to be was a missionary. As I got to the teen years, life slowly drowned my ambitions, and I settled for a ho-hum life with my own weaknesses to tempt me and my Father's teaching to save me.
From the age of 14-16 I seriously considered leaving God altogether. I refused to read my Bible and drew into myself and closed the door. I changed into the person many people wanted me to be. Silent, mature, and intelligent when I needed to speak.
As I got older, I knew that my only hope to go on living would be in faith, but I felt so wicked and so far from God that I did not how to proceed. I could not go tell my parents any of this, because I didn't want them to know, and the sins in their lives seemed to have them at the same point as I was.
So, I went to Journey seeking. I found there a lot of healing, but less answers than I had wanted, and some answers I DIDN't want. I found out what a real RELATIONSHIP with God was, and what love was (more on that later).
I credit Journey with all that I am now, because without it I would be stuck where I was before, getting more and more frustrated and maybe even so angry that I would give up everything I have learned over the past 4 years.
If any of you want to write me for some more personal thoughts on this, or anything else, I made a gmail address to go along with the blog: Defraudeddaughter@gmail.com
A link to my testimony on Living The Journey
I know that there are a lot of “Gothard survivors” out there, and I empathize with them deeply.
My father went to his first Gothard seminar as a young man. He said it affected him profoundly, and he took my mother to one when they were still dating. She latched on to it as well, and in our house the 3 volume “Character Sketches” tomes were on hand as a resource....
But we rarely ever used them.
Despite the good things they liked about Gothard, my parents never ended up joining ATI or have gone beyond attending Advanced and Anger Resolution Seminars. However, my father did use “youth conflicts” materials as a basis for a “Principles for Progress in Life” (PPL) seminar he used for a while where we were missionaries. After a while, when he had established a reputation in the community and had a handful of converts, he moved into more of a discipleship program than a salvation one, and PPL digressed to the annals of our history.
However, admiration for Gothard has remained strong, and lately my mother has been using the Character Sketches books more for their Bible stories and picture worth.
I attended Basic when I was 15, after we moved to the States for good. I think I did advanced, but I don't remember when, and I did Anger Resolution just a few years ago. (2007, I think)
I respected Mr Gothard for the scripture in what he taught and because my parents looked up to him as a great Bible Scholar and teacher.
So, when I was out looking for a place to “get away” I was not very surprised when my father pulled up the ponderous list of ATI alumni activities. I had set my heart on attending TeenPact's Endeavor, but due to money constraints, I did not register soon enough, and I would be down about 15 on the waiting list. So, my father encouraged me to look elsewhere.
Journey to the Heart stuck out to me because it was near Chicago (I have always liked that city for some reason), because I could visit friends out in that area while I was out there (another reason for liking the city), and because it promised me a whole new walk with God. I had come through a lot on the plane that separates stagnation and passion, and I could never seem to find balance.
Saved as a young child, living as a Christian meant little to me. As I hit the double digits all I wanted to be was a missionary. As I got to the teen years, life slowly drowned my ambitions, and I settled for a ho-hum life with my own weaknesses to tempt me and my Father's teaching to save me.
From the age of 14-16 I seriously considered leaving God altogether. I refused to read my Bible and drew into myself and closed the door. I changed into the person many people wanted me to be. Silent, mature, and intelligent when I needed to speak.
As I got older, I knew that my only hope to go on living would be in faith, but I felt so wicked and so far from God that I did not how to proceed. I could not go tell my parents any of this, because I didn't want them to know, and the sins in their lives seemed to have them at the same point as I was.
So, I went to Journey seeking. I found there a lot of healing, but less answers than I had wanted, and some answers I DIDN't want. I found out what a real RELATIONSHIP with God was, and what love was (more on that later).
I credit Journey with all that I am now, because without it I would be stuck where I was before, getting more and more frustrated and maybe even so angry that I would give up everything I have learned over the past 4 years.
If any of you want to write me for some more personal thoughts on this, or anything else, I made a gmail address to go along with the blog: Defraudeddaughter@gmail.com
A link to my testimony on Living The Journey
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)