Showing posts with label books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books. Show all posts

January 31, 2014

Keep Your Filthy Hands Away from My Family

  There seems to be a trend, when people come out of the wood work and attempt to change the status quo, of "discrediting" that person in attempt to inhibit or block their work.  Perhaps some of the most insidious examples of this are people who use their life story as an example and a catalyst for change.
  "This happened to me." 
A trend I am seeing, in silencing the voices of homeschoolers or former homeschoolers who have suffered educational neglect and potentially other more serious consequences of isolation and total parental control over every aspect of their lives, is that of using one's siblings to discredit the other sibling.

Stacy McDonald used Hillary McFarland's sister as a method of making Hillary's groundbreaking book seem like the dramatic rendition of a "vivid imagination."  Interestingly enough, her book and blog sparked a fire that is still setting free quiverfull daughters like me. 
As noted in Quivering Daughters not all homeschooling families are quiverfull and patriarchal, but patriarchal and quiverfull homes will most likely be homeschool homes as well.

See, the problem with using siblings (like Josh Powell's sibling) to discredit potential laws and books written in the face of the "homeschooling produces excellent results every time" and "no abuse here" and "homeschooled girls are so great because they are victorian" is that it tears apart families and makes the point about "she-said-she-said" and not: This is a serious issue that cannot continue.  This needs to be addressed and dealt with.

Children being homeschooled have no rights. 
Daughters under strongly religious families are repeatedly beat down into caricatures of what their families think was best about the past, crippled with sub-standard educations and stunted mentally, emotionally, and spiritually.
Sons are forced to become "entrepreneurs" instead of "wage slaves chained to desks" and bound to a life of poverty with their futures stolen.

I am angry and I am scared.

See, I have multiple younger siblings still living at home, which is the main reason for my anonymity.  I want to protect them and their way of life, even while I try to dismantle it from the outside.  I know that my parents have been reported for educational neglect (by others and neighbors), but the state they live in has not decided to do anything about it.  I have not lived there in over 3 years, or been allowed to see any siblings under the age of 18.  I get only small glimpses from my older brother or my oldest younger brother when he calls me.

IF I WERE TO SPEAK OUT using my own name, how many of my younger siblings could come foreward and say that I was lying? 
Many of them were not spanked like my older brother was, mostly because my parents no longer had the time to individually deal with offenses.  "Creative punishments" like chores, or enforced hugging, or writing verses were used more, or periods of verbal berating. 
Many of them are males, and therefore will not receive the same kind of spiritual abuse I did, being told that God would not speak to me because I was a child (meaning I had a living father) and a woman.
The younger children have no idea what our father did because it is a "hush hush" family secret so that no one knows that he has no integrity.
 Thats the thing about sin, if you hide all of yours and dont let anyone tell, you look perfect. 

They could easily say that I was "being overly dramatic" about leaving the RP and what happened to the former ministry there.
In fact, many people would back them up on that point.  I was dramatic as a child, singing made-up opera songs at the top of my lungs to get attention.
I also was a "perennial liar" because I would often attempt to tweak the truth or get out of a punishment by inventing white lies or using "deception" as my mom would call it often.  "Not telling the WHOLE truth is deception, and therefore a lie and a sin."  SO, if I got the whole house cleaned, but spent some time on the computer as well; telling her that I worked all afternoon is a deception, a sin, and a LIE.  See, I am not to be believed. 

Anyone who knows my name could get my older brother (who still is a fundamentalist patriarch in beliefs) to "discredit" loads of things that are my empirical evidence, based on his empirical evidence.

But guess what: KEEP YOUR FILTHY HANDS AWAY FROM MY FAMILY!
HSLDA, and the McDonalds, and anyone else who feels like using sibling against sibling in order to keep their money-making, influential empires intact.
I am here to break down your system, and my family is not a pawn in your game.
When I do break out of my anonymity, I will not allow you to use them against me.
And for those who have already done so (specifically those mentioned above): For Shame.

Shame, shame, shame upon you and your name and legacy.
Your hands are tainted with the shame to which you stoop.
Your legacy is smeared by the abuse you defend and allow to continue.
You have no credibility, so you hurt that of those who do, using the few people who might be able to damage them.  And you use a family to do it.  You are not defenders of the family, but wreckers.

Shame.

September 8, 2011

Harry Potter pt. 6

The last movie I saw in a theater.  I was hoping to finish the rest of the movies in time and I am glad I did.
It spends a lot of time explaining and tying up loose ends.  It also flashes back and plays the scene where Harry's mother dies and I could not stop crying.  Like, overwhelming sobbing that made the people in the theater uncomfortable with me.

It has an interesting take on death.  Not unlike the Princess Bride's 'mostly dead.'  Apparently the effects of the shield of love his mother created gave him the choice to 'go back' to life.  It isnt fully explained, but even without him his friends were going to keep fighting evil.  Also, those who are dead (like Harry's parents and guardians) claim to have been always present during the events of the film.  Death is not an end, but a change in the 'level' to which you can do and be. I want to think on that some more before I talk about it because the idea fascinates me.
One thing that I did not like was his repeated insistence that others were dying for him.  HE may have been the chosen one, but he wasnt the end-all be-all.  They were fighting for their way of life and for freedom to not be under a cruel, totalitarian dictator who would have killed up to 75% of them for blood purification reasons.

We learn that some people have been fighting for love all along and it looks different depending on the presuppositions of the one watching/judging.  We see some people make bad decisions and come to regret them.  They are dubbed 'evil' because of family history, race, proximity to evil, and/or opportunity.  Everyone is naturally selfish or jealous.  It is called sin and it is in us as much as it is in them. 
The key is compassion and forgiveness.  And evidence of a real change and time to heal and be apart for a while.  Reconciliation is not impossible.

One aspect that struck me was that one can piece apart their soul and place it in or on something and remain an influence.  I find it a fascinating concept as well as a possible truth.  I think places and things can hold memory.  I think human emotions and person-hood leave more than just a spiritual trail behind them.  Places of beauty are such because people go there to be happy.  Houses that are dark are that way because people fight and hate inside them.  (Think: the House of Seven Gables)
Wands in Harry Potter choose and feel and are beings that have loyalty and power of their own.  Yet, they cannot (without a person commanding them) create any spells or use themselves to do magic.  Thus the things we wear, the car we drive, our belongings contain a bit of ourselves, or a bit of their former owner(s).
That concept fascinates me and I really would like to ask God about it one day.

But in the end, we find that

September 7, 2011

Harry Potter pt. 5

In the 6th movie we see a lot of authorities using those underneath them.  The evil ones do it right alongside the 'good.'  We excuse the 'good' because it seems the most expedient things at the time (not to mention we are cheering for them inside), but the evil one we condemn for using a 'child' instead of being brave enough to do the job himself.
There is one strong undergirding theme of respect and trust being earned. You cannot invade another person's mind or memory without their consent.  You cannot get a spot in the inner circle without earning a good grade in class by trying/studying.

We see again the people cannot be trusted to reveal to us their true motives.  Pretenses get cast away in the heat of the moment and in the crush of real.  There is an interesting message where one person goes with a 'gut feeling.'  I was taught all my life that the 'heart is deceitful and desperately wicked' and that feelings or 'gut' urges were sin just because of their origin.  If you find out later that it wasn't, oops.  Otherwise, you do well by blocking this sin the moment it enters your mind.
Sometimes..... gut feelings can have bearing on the situation and sometimes you may be right.

There are some humorous moments where 'love' and 'attraction' are taken too far and we see that not all 'gut' feelings are true or lasting.  The moral there was to stick close to the people who have stuck with you.  For years:your best friends.  They may end up being more than friends later on....

The 7th movie is more heavy on the storyline then anything else but we see some good stuff.  Dark magic causes depressed feelings and fighting among Harry and his friends. We see that sometimes before fighting about the issue at hand it is better to remove the things that are muddying the waters in the first place.  Clear heads dont waste time and resources screaming at one another.
We see that no matter what the personal cost friendship and love is worth sacrificing for.  We are encouraged to cry when a side character stands up for himself and defends others even as he is killed.  We see a 'bad' person hesitate at a moment of triumph and we see a 'good' person turn other people in to evil out of hope for gain.

We also see someone being confronted with their worst fears.  I think a person's fears tell us more about who they are then their hopes or dreams, so I loved this scene (in a twisted way, knowing it would turn out alright).  His worst fear consisted of spiders (same here), his mother wishing he was a daughter, his best friend belittling him, and the girl he loved ditching him for the person in the spotlight.
When faced with the apparitions of complete rejection, he is paralyzed.  He lays there wondering, wasting precious seconds, if any of it is true, if all of it is true, if anything he knew was true.
And then the voice of his best friend reminds him of the situation and he slays the creature giving rise to the doubts.

My only question is: how do the evil ones know of our worst fears?  Can the devil read minds?  How do they know exactly where our weakest points are?
It plagues me that no matter where I go and no matter what success I achieve in life or over my personal issues, my worst fears are going to be thrown in my face and are expected to cripple, maim, or even completely incapacitate me.....

And that this isnt something I can change.

September 6, 2011

Harry Potter pt. 4

In the 5th movie we find the power of love.
People who hate do cruel and evil things.  People who hate turn dark inside.  Sometimes it doesnt even take hate.  Indifference, depression, disgust: all these things have the power to turn you dark inside.

In the 5th movie we find that some people are faithful even until death with secrets and refuse to be used by evil.  We find that authority without respect, understanding, and honesty results in those under it's control having to hide.  They pretend, obeying outwardly and fight against every rule.  They band together and devote all their time and energy to thwarting the fierce control levied over them, even to the point where they are told they deserve punishment for pretending (when they are telling the truth).
They find that obedience would render them infantile and useless and they rebel.
They form fast friendships, hiding secrets and being there for eachother.  They refuse to break up and together they face powers much bigger, older, stronger and are able to change the course of a battle.

And they are just children

Control breeds rebellion. 
Freedom and careful teaching create wise and powerful individuals who can decide for themselves how and when to act.
Harry find that he can see things others cannot because he has 'seen death.'
He is at the same time hurt and helped by his past.  And even through nightmares, pain, struggles, and victory it does not change. He cannot change his past any more than we can.

One final thing: Harry finally finds his happy memories.  Using them he refuses the Dark Lord's possession of his mind.  He speaks softly and gives him the ultimate blow: "You're the weak one. And you'll never know love,or friendship. And I feel sorry for you."
Even in our world, love has a tremendous and overwhelming power.  My father does not have love or friendship.  He has control and power and fear.  And he has children who have run away from his tryannical reign.  He does not have a wife/helpmeet.  He has a house-elf who serves and obeys and cannot question.
He does not have colleagues.  He has a posse of followers who may or may not stay faithful if he disappears.
And while I dont feel sorry for him, I wish I could.

September 5, 2011

Harry Potter pt. 3


Harry longs for his parents.  He never got to know them and the little memories he has been able to salvage are pitifully inadequate for any person.  Coming from a dysfunctional family, I understand his pain.  I can remember the couple of times that I felt loved by my father and a handful of times that my mother and I enjoyed eachother's company unreservedly.

In the second movie he finds that he has a many of the same powers and talents and the same bent as the Dark Lord and the 'bad' wizards.  He spends a lot of time afraid to turn 'bad.'
The 'sage' of the movies reminds him of a deep truth: it is not our past or what others were or what we seem to be like, but our CHOICES that affect our future.  Harry's choices made him who he was and if he wanted to he could be the darkest of all.  If he chose, he could also stay on the path of being a friend and doing good.
I also love the many mythical things that crop up in the movies, such as (in this one) a mirror which shows us as having accomplished our deepest desires/wants/goals.  It shows you yourself truly happy.


In the 3rd installment we find that Harry is negatively affected more than anyone else at the school by the daemon-creatures that suck out happiness and joy because he has had 'true horrors' in his past.  He blacks out and is unable to accomplish much of anything against them.  In order to repel them you have to have a happy memory to focus on, or some indecent of true joy to block them with.
The power of this memory creates a 'shield' and a strong enough one would repel the attacker.

The parallels with real life are enormous.  I often find that one of the few things that bring me out of my place of pain or loneliness or depression is the strength of my memories and the pieces of joy in my past.

In the 4th movie someone places Harry in a contest in hopes to either kill him or get him to a place where the Dark Power can use his blood to come back to life (a bit creepy, yes).  A companion is killed and Harry has the choice to run or fight and he decides to die bravely.  In a matter of wands and such, the victims of the Dark Lord come out and attack him, creating a shield which again saves Harry.
We find out about a father who was so dedicated to his career that he lost his only son, who then turns around and kills his father and serves the Dark Lord gladly.  We find the teachers and parents keep information from Harry and his friends which would be useful to know.  I dont know why parents cant be honest and up front.  'Ready' or not, eventually children are going to become adults and need to know.  (But I wont get any more off topic here)  We see that kindness is appreciated by some, if not by many.  And we learn that things are not always as they seem.  The best of intentions may have some underlying evil motive. 

September 4, 2011

Harry Potter pt. 2

Beginning this I want to be honest and say that one of the biggest reasons I wanted to watch the movie series was a "how close can I get to the line but not cross it" motive.
A facebook friend posted a video from a 'former witch' that had the usual "there is a huge hidden conspiracy in schools and modern culture to take your children" fearmongering I had heard a million times before about everything from Jeans to Rock Music to Barbie Dolls.
I am a QF/Patriarchy daughter who 'ran away' from home at 20.  Ive already been called all sorts of descriptive names and 'rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft' doesnt scare me.  Use a blank threat too many times and I wont believe anything you say or quote.  Also, nearly all the world knows about the book series and the movies are bound to be bigger than Titanic.  I read other books because of their 'classic' status, I wasnt going to stay away from HP just because of a worn out line that says I am going to become a witch.

Next Disclaimer:
The nature of writing is flawed in that interpretations can be taken from it based on the mindset and presuppositions of the readers.  Take the Bible for instance.  How many religions and factions and bad things have come out of man's attempts to make sense of it over the past 2,000 years?
In watching the HP movies, my interpretation of them and the things I see may or may not jump out at others.  They may not even be there at all for some.  However, the things that I am seeing I want to share.  So take everything with a grain of salt.

In the first movie we meet a lonely boy who has been treated like a slave by his aunt and uncle.  His cousin feels obviously superior and they all look down on him.  Strange things happen around him and he isnt quite sure why or how.
And then he finds out that he has been lied to his whole life.  His aunt was jealous of her sister and upset at her life choices and hoped to keep Harry from his destiny.  Needless to say, she and her controlling husband are unsuccessful.
Harry begins to learn about what really happened to his parents and the secrets of his past.  He is allowed to make innocent/childish mistakes and some of his teachers care for him like parents.
In the climax: a battle with his nemesis, we find out that his mother's death created a magic around him so old that it changed the world.  She blocked the killing curse meant for him.
A sacrificial death.

I made this picture my computer background and when I look at it I can see love.

July 31, 2011

Ha**y Potte*

Alas, here again I come face-to-face with my  past.
I fear writing out confessions like this because one-upon-a-time I debated (frothing at the mouth) against those who would dare read, veiw, or consider (reading or indulging in) the Harry Potter books and movie series.
I remember two such occasions very clearly, but undoubtedly there were more.

Honestly, now, the most radical change in my outlook has come from a lack of fear.
To a great degree the reasons we were discouraged from ever showing interest in HP was because of the fear-mongering.  "Let your child read HP and before you know it they will become wiccans!"
"HP teaches children the basic lower levels of spells.  Soon they will have evil spirits they can command."
"J.K. Rowling is a secret witch.  These books are an effort to make more witches and spread demon possession to the rest of the world....." etc, etc
(and no, I dont think any of these are extreme.  I have heard all of these in various ways and more)

A second reason, I believe, is due to a lot more faith in myself.
I dont think I am stupid enough to believe that I can replicate spells and try them and turn into a witch.
I dont think I will be 'taken in' by this evil message.  I am smarter than that and I am not afraid of it.

What is wrong with reading a novel?  Is it 'sin'?
In short, no.  There is NOTHING wrong with reading, or with reading books that the world likes a lot, or with reading books that may portray actions and behaviors that you might not indulge in.  Like a murder mystery.  Reading an Agatha Christie novel wont turn you into a killer any more than reading Harry Potter will turn you into a witch, wizard, or wiccan.

Use your mind.  It is your greatest asset and your best organ.  Take all advice with a grain of salt.  Think through things carefully and make up your own mind.
And live!!  Live fully and with joy.
What more can we desire for a good life?

September 10, 2010

The Worst of all Possible Reactions

"The heart," as Pascal said, "has its reasons that reason knows not of." Something in us longs, or hopes, maybe even at times believes that this is not the way things were supposed to be. Our desire fights the assault of death upon life. And so people with terminal illnesses get married. Prisoners in a concentration camp plant flowers. Lovers long divorced still reach out in the night to embrace one who is no longer there. Its like the phantom pain experienced by those who have lost a limb. Feelings still emanate from that region where once was a crucial part of them, and they will sometimes find themselves being careful not to bang the corner of a table or slam the car door on a leg or arm long since removed. Our hearts know a similar reality. At some deep level, we refuse to accept the fact that this is the way things are, or must be, or always will be.

Simone Weil was right, there are only two things that pierce the human heart: beauty and affliction. Moments we wish would last forever and moments we wish had never begun. What are we to make of these messengers? How are we to interpret what they are saying? As the playwright Christopher Fry wrote,

The inescapable dramatic situation for us all is that we have no idea what our situation is. We may be mortal. What then? We may be immortal. What then? We are plunged into an existence fantastic to the point of nightmare, and however hard we rationalize, or however firm our religious faith, however closely we dog the heels of science or wheel among the starts of mysticism, we cannot really make head or tail of it.

And what does Fry say we do with our dilemma? The worst of all possible reactions:

We get used to it. We get broken into it so gradually we scarcely notice it.

(Desire , 8.9)
From the RHM daily readings

September 1, 2010

Acculturation

In thinking about "culture shock" recently I said this:

I guess I have had culture shock on two drastically different levels, being an MK/TCK and coming "home" to a different culture than I was used to, as well as now leaving the "family bubble" and meeting the big, bad, ugly world.

I think depending on how prepared you are for it, and how your outlook is, it can be a good thing.  For instance, leaving home I knew I was going to be shocked on multiple levels, so hearing people talk crassly about sex and use cuss words I expected and I can blush deep red and go on with life.  I am expecting all manner of horrible things to happen, because part of the "Bubble Curriculum" is informing children about how terrible everything outside the bubble is and how it would destroy anyone without a similar bubble *queue a handful of sad examples.

On the other hand, coming to the US was very difficult for me...  All I really knew about this place was that it was "different" and had cold winters.  I had been here for a couple months in 2002, but I had gone about it with the air of a visitor or tourist, never imagining that in two years I would be living here "forever."  It took me almost 3 years to adjust and get to the point where I was "ok with" (not comfortable, but not intensely afraid) going around, meeting people, and the general tone/atmosphere of the country.
I also noticed after I wrote it that I have been taking steps to deliberately acculturate myself.  Watching TV and popular movies, listening to pop music, and allowing people to do things around me that would normally be an affront to my standards. (Oh, and explain a lot of things to me.  Like what a certain word or gesture means....*hem)
It is a pretty embarrassing process.  And I keep trying to find a balance.  I don't mind being innocent of a lot of stuff that other people never got to not know.  But I don't want to be innocently stupid, either.


An update about reading the Message:
I am enjoying Romans.  I flipped through the OT, and wasn't too interested.  I tried the Gospels for a couple pages and could not stand it.  I don't talk that way.  I don't read that way.  I mean, I grew up reading Les Miserables and The Robe and The Count of Monte Cristo.  I decided not to force myself, so I went on.  Acts is over-read and I don't care to read about doctrinal/church issues, so I landed in Romans.  It is interesting, seeing it as a paragraph in a chapter.  The lack of verses I really like.  I am going slowly, and most people would probably say I should read daily, but I don't.  When I remember I do.

In other news, I almost have my GED.  It has taken me an absurd amount of time and effort jumping all hoops and time requirements and assigned times.  I don't know my scores, but the proctor sure got to know me!  I finished reading before she expected (15 minutes) and in writing the day before I finished first as well.  I purposely took a long time in math, because I didn't want to be the first one done.  I sat and thought and wrote out a ton on my scrap paper and once one person finished I reviewed my figures and finished up. I was the 3rd.  Today is the final leg of tests.
Everything is pretty easy.  I should totally pass..... should.....

August 25, 2010

Denial

Denial is a favorite method of coping for many Christians. But not with Jesus. He wants truth in the inmost being, and to get it there he's got to take us into our inmost being. One way he'll do this is by bringing up an old memory. You'll be driving down the road and suddenly remember something from your childhood. Or maybe you'll have a dream about a long-forgotten person, event, or place. However he brings it up, go with him there. He has something to say to you.

The lessons that have been laid down in pain can be accessed only in pain. Christ must open the wound, not just bandage it over. Sometimes he'll take us there by having an event repeat itself years later, only with new characters in the current situation. We find ourselves overlooked for a job, just as we were overlooked by our parents. Or we experience fear again, just as we felt those lonely nights in our room upstairs. These are all invitations to go with him into the deep waters of the heart, uncover the lies buried down there, and bring in the truth that will set us free. Don't just bury it quickly; ask God what he is wanting to speak to.

(Waking the Dead , 122)

August 20, 2010

Book Review: Preparing to Be a Helpmeet

Book Review: Preparing to Be A Helpmeet

Ok, so this book I did not choose to read, or buy or anything. My mother was given a copy at a Ladies Bible Study she began going to, and she pushed it at me and said “tell me what you think.” I had just had my Wisdom teeth out, so during my convalescing, I decided “Why not.”

About: This book is for “young, bright eyed girls” who are planning on getting married. (“planning” meaning more along the lines of: older teen girl reading all the required books to older old-maid who doesn't know why she isn't married yet)
It is a wide brush that goes over the necessities of knowledge, planning, creativity, and compatibility to make a marriage.


Positives: While she does go into the whole “Courtship Story” thing, she does it in a way that does NOT paint a “this is how you need to do it” picture. WAY to many books out there set out models or say “at least incorporate these couple (dozen?) elements.” She does not even hint as to a “model.”
She also encourages seeking peace in one's decisions. Obviously there is a big emphasis on authorities and input from them, but she does give a section to a girl's personal decision. One part seemed a bit positive on “arranged” marriage, but it was slight.

I am not sure what audience she is writing for, but she does a good job in encouraging girls to be learning and learning and too keep on learning. She casts girls who sit at home and wait to be picked up in a negative light, and all the “good examples” are girls who are out serving God, working for a mission or a ministry, and accomplishing something with their lives.

Negatives:
My main negative in this book is that it is all directed at the girls. Now, DUH, this is a book TO girls, but it is written in such a way as to make me feel that the fate of my marriage is just about entirely on my shoulders. My preparation and my conduct is THE deciding factor and one fault of mine could ruin my marriage.
My first red flag was her telling me that women are the “man's image.” (Ch. 6, p 68) Man, she says, is in the image of the godhead (trinity), and we women (taken from their side) are in the man's image, and therefore “Our goal is to conform to being the type of woman our man needs...” (Reflections on Chapter 6, p. 128)

She spent 3 chapters on each of her three “types” of men (taken almost directly from Created to Be His Helpmeet) and then makes 3 categories for women under that and spends on chapter on all of them. She lumped them together and only really explained how each of the “girl types” fits with each guy type. [Note: I skipped all of chapter 5. My father is her “command man/King” type and it was really triggering for me to hear her gush about this type]

One confusing thing for me was trying to figure out what audience she is targeting. She speaks very angrily about vaccinations, encourages long hair and herbal healing and such. What I got from the middle chapters was that unless I was an issues-free, joyful-faced, smiling, well presented, and capable, hardworking type of girl....I wasn't marriageable material.
She has men commenting in little blurbs all through the book, and one of them says “Don't complain. Ever.” She tells girls that standing against (in disagreement with) your husband = standing against God. (Chapter 7, p 93) She says that stubbornness is a “masculine trait” and therefore unacceptable in a female.

Chapter 11 she jumps on texting. At first I thought it pretty funny until I realized the bigger picture. I don't know about other families, but my Father often picks one thing and blames everything on that. For Debi Pearl, the quantum of all evil is texting. She has a handful of negative examples and one horror story, and makes all kinds of statements about it. For instance:
“...internet 'love' is not real.” , she says that texting is used by the Devil to destroy lives, and “...there cannot be an honest, clean, courtship through texting.”
In this chapter she also deals with “seconds.” You know, the impure people? She gives an example (cast in a positive light) of a girl who turns a guy away because she didn't want her future children to have a “daddy with baggage.” The other (horror) story ends with the guy choosing a “nice, chaste girl who didn't text...” because the texting girl was an “already licked candy bar” (p. 139).
She finishes the chapter with a heavy admonition to girls. Because: “To get to know a man who is not your husband is emotional adultery. To exchange intimate knowledge with several guys is whorish.” (p. 139)


Chapter 15 deals with “honor” and sin. She talks about how her greatest hate/fear was spiders and how when she was speaking/thinking negatively about someone “God was waiting to give me [judgment] the first time my guard was down...” and her subsequent run-in with the biggest, ugliest and hairiest eight-legged monster. She then lets a friend tell her story of 3 separate issues with flea infestations when she ignored her husband's words/admonitions or thought that she knew better than he did.

She finishes up this chapter with the most terrible statement in the entire book: (p. 188) (for a girl raised by a “dominant, forceful father”)
“Life is easier for girls raised by dominant, forceful fathers because they are accustomed to obeying. They were never given any other option and grew accustomed to strong authority. In contrast, girls raised by kind, gentle fathers often get bitter toward their husbands if they are demanding.”
(I guess she expects husbands to be demanding and forceful? You have to assume a lot in this book)

Chapter 16 types depression as some sort of petty created problem: “...every black depression stems from someone 'supposing' another meant evil toward them, used the, thought offensively toward them, or whatever else the mind contrives. Imagine being free from all these misapprehensions!”

The final chapter is a word from some men. Her husband first, and another man after. I was glad it was in the back of the book, because it made me want to quit reading altogether, but I shall tell you about it anyway.
The other guy is apparently a preacher and he talks about a time when they needed an immediate emergency plumbing done the same time he was offered a preaching time at a prison he had been trying to get into for a long time. His wife offered to do the plumbing, and from the way he talks, she does everything and he is blessed to be free to preach, which is his calling. Reading it I sat there and wondered why he was married in the first place if his calling to preach was so important that his wife did EVERYTHING else (homeschooling, housework, plumbing, bills, etc, etc,etc). She may be his helpmeet, but she isn't helping him with anything when she is doing it all herself. But that is just me.

Now, on to the first comments, which some of you will please skip over due to the heart attack risk. I just about threw the book across the room. Michael Pearl gives us a look into what he tells “all” the guys who ask him what to look for in a woman. And, he then twists it into a benign character quality to make every single girl on the planet definite “trouble”. The quote in it's entirety says:
“I tell young men, if a young woman thinks she is a real catch, then know she is not. If she feels she is doing you a favor marrying you, then know for a fact you are marrying trouble. Make sure she feels blessed that you have chosen her. Keep searching until you find a girl with the most valuable of all character traits: a thankful heart.” [Chapter 17, p.206]

So, unless I fall at this guys feet in worship and say “ME?!?!? You are going to marry ME!?!?! Oh, you are SOOOOOO out of my league, I am BLESSED that *I* am your chosen bride” I am un-thankful piece of trouble?
So, that is the advice to men. For women it is: “Become the woman he needs.”



In summary, I think this book will convict a lot of women. We are only too willing to believe that we are at fault and only to willing to expend atomic bombs of energy to fix things we believe need to be fixed and repair what we are told we have damaged. The problem is that this will only work where the women are at fault. “Happily Ever After” will never happen when only one person is working to make things better! And since the men are told to find a woman who worships them and excused when they are demanding, insensitive, and forceful, they are not likely to see any place they need to change or work.
Heaven pity the poor women (girls) who follow this book.

June 4, 2010

Book Quote

I signed up for the daily emails from RHM, which are various quotes from their books.
I REALLY am devouring Waking the Dead, and I loved this quote they sent Wednesday:


I was reading the prophet Jeremiah a few weeks ago when I ran across a passage that referred to God as "the Lord Almighty." To be honest, it didn't resonate. There's something too religious about the phrase; it sounds churchy, sanctimonious. The Lawd Almiiiighty. It sounds like something your grandmother would say when you came into her kitchen covered in mud. I found myself curious about what the actual phrase means in Hebrew. Might we have lost something in the translation? So I turned to the front of the version I was using for an explanation. Here is what the editors said:

Because for most readers today the phrases "the Lord of hosts" and "God of hosts" have little meaning, this version renders them "the Lord Almighty" and "God Almighty." These renderings convey the sense of the Hebrew, namely, "he who is sovereign over all the "hosts' (powers) in heaven and on earth, especially over the "hosts' (armies) of Israel."

No, they don't. They don't even come close. The Hebrew means "the God of angel armies," "the God of the armies who fight for his people." The God who is at war. Does "Lord Almighty" convey "the God who is at war"? Not to me, it doesn't. Not to anyone I've asked. It sounds like "the God who is up there but still in charge." Powerful, in control. The God of angel armies sounds like the one who would roll up his sleeves, take up sword and shield to break down gates of bronze, and cut through bars of iron to rescue me.

(Waking the Dead , 160)

May 30, 2010

Book Review: Love and War

I am pretty much an Eldredge Fan. Well, more like I LOVE Captivating and I am working through Waking the Dead slowly and surely.

When I found that they had a new book out, I jumped at the chance to get a copy. Well, more like I really wanted to read it, but was afraid. See, it is a book on marriage.
Now, I am not married, and unmarried girls reading marriage books just puts out a message of: “Trying too hard”, or “too desperate”, or something along those lines.

But I really wanted to read it because I wanted to know what a good marriage looks like. I wanted desperately to have some model or some frame of reference to use if I ever do get anyone interested in me. It is pitiful, I guess. I was talking with a dear girl (I believe I referenced her before as “S”) about marriage and our conversation went like this:


Me:...and I hear that those (good marriages) are hard
In fact, most of the ones I see are not what I want
for myself or my children
“S”: to be honest, I've never really seen 'unhappy marriages'... heard of them... but not really known anyone in one
Me: come to our house
have yourself a lesson
(I know of) parents who kiss and do silly lover-like stuff a lot
and they have had like 10 kids and are in their 50s
I just can't understand or imagine
its sad really
I have been doing a lot of reading of marriage books and the like...trying to get enough head knowledge for if I ever get (to) the real thing
“S”: I'm so sorry for you... I can't understand or imagine your situation...

I feel the same way. I have NO idea what it is like to have parents who really care for one another. My mother protested to my brother just the other day that she “really loves” daddy (it was their 25th Wedding Anniversary). But somehow her love gets lost in his demands and brusqueness and the drag of the life behind the masks.

But I am not writing this out to drag their personal lives out on the Internet. It is just that all the marriages I have personally experienced/been around (not many beyond family) are not what I would want for myself or for my children. I have heard of people who ARE happily married, and some close friends seem to have parents that are like that....but I really don't know their parents or see them much.

Love and War starts out by dashing all the “diamond sunbursts and marble halls” of young dreamers. “Marriage is hard” they say over and over again. And they prove it by looking deeply into what each of us know all too well—the brokenness deep within us. They break from other books by talking frankly and openly about the difficulties of living with another broken, “royally messed up” human being. They state that the purpose of marriage is for God to use this one person as His special “transforming tool” in your life. By living in close and constant communion with this other soul, you need to be forgiving, gentle, relentlessly loving, and try your utmost to be self-sacrificing.

It was a good read. I got through it in two sittings, and it flows easily and engages at the same time. I will probably lend it to a couple people (and my BFF already asked me to let her read it after I was done with it) I have talked to about it, and I will definitely keep it handy to read again in the future.

They break from their other books in that L&W is very light on the movie references. I know that context makes them generally understandable in intent, but for those of us culturally clueless when it comes to Star Wars or The Matrix there is only a random occurrence.
I admire how open and free they are. Writing is a scary thing, because you are baring a part of yourself, your thoughts and dreams and plans and way of thinking to another....to many others.
There are times that writing on this blog feels like I am baring my heart to the entire world. It is scary, and definitely intensely personal. They share their hearts, and it encourages you to get up off the couch and fight. To love with abandon. To engage in the war for the redemption of humankind from evil. To follow God with every ounce in you.
And they promise that it can be done.

May 25, 2010

Musty Old Books

The other day, as we were packing up books the other day, I found a couple that looked worth a reading. SO there I was skimming this book by A.W. Tozer, when I randomly switched chapters and flipped towards the end of the book.

I came upon chapter 9, and read these words:
But, quickly and on the other hand, it must be said that there is absolutely no scriptural authority, neither precept nor biblical example, to allow any husband to behave as a brutal lord, ruling his home with an iron hand...
You can continue through Old Testament history and although it was a bit in the shadows compared with the New Testament, still and nevertheless, there was never and brutal masculine domination in the families with whom God was dealing....
Certainly the Bible picture is plain in denying the husband any right to be a dominating despot delighting in hard-handed dealings with his wife and family....
Peter is advising the husband to use his head and the common sense he has been given: "...giving honor unto the wife, as unto the weaker vessel, and as being heirs of the grace of life." In other words, husband and wife are children of God together, equal heirs of the grace of life.


And later:
Now, Peter makes a very strong comment in this passage for the benefit of husbands. (Chapter 3 verse 7) I suppose there are many Christian husbands whose prayers are not being answered and they can think up lots of reasons. But the fact is that thoughtless husbands are simply big, overbearing clods when it comes to consideration of their wives....
A husband's spiritual problems do not lie in the Kremlin nor in the Vatican but in the heart of the man himself--in his attitude and inability to resist the temptation to grumble, and growl, and dominate! There is no place for that kind of male rulership in any Christian home.


I was intrigued by this 1970's perspective. What do you say?